Much has been made of the traditional aspects of US military formations and ceremonies, including whether or not prayer and the Chaplaincy–which has been part of military protocol since George Washington’s time–is appropriate.

While not directly addressing the controversy of religion, Maj Thomas Smicklas has written a fascinating and heartfelt commentary on the meaning of military ceremonies and their time-honored traditions: 

The Air Force has many different types of ceremonies that are unique customs of our military profession. Retreats, decorations, changes of command, promotions, re-enlistments and retirements are just a few of the ceremonies that you will attend throughout your service to our country.  Not only is it a way to say thank you, but it gives you an opportunity to reflect on your service and your commitment to the Air Force and our nation.

By listening to the speaker, standing when asked, and quietly observing the ceremony, you are paying respect to both the individual and to our Air Force. It’s your way of saying I appreciate what you did and thank you for working so hard to make a difference.

Though surrounded by a culture in which traditions are increasingly eschewed as backward and old fashioned, the military remains a closed society that still relies on customs, courtesies, honor, and tradition.

Despite some isolated criticisms, that’s not always a bad thing.