An interesting article covers the South Korean response to the homecoming of the 19 remaining hostages held by the Taliban. Notably, there seems to be a backlash to apparent “overzealous proselytizing,” even though
Both Saemmul Presbyterian Church, to which the hostages belong, and the government insisted that the hostages had not been proselytizing, just providing aid. But many religious experts here consider such a distinction meaningless, since South Korean churches provide aid to gain converts.
Why does this matter to the military Christian? There is a growing movement in America that is reflected here by the quoted “many religious experts:” the supposition that Christians can’t separate their “overtly proselytizing ways” from their other actions–whether they be charitable or governmental. That is, Christians can’t help but proselytize, and they must be treated as if they will.
Some people seem to think that if the military forbids proselytizing in its ranks then it must restrict the actions of Christians, because Christians cannot help but proselytize. The cultural view of Christianity bears significant impact on the religious freedom of Christians in the military.
As previously reported on the Religion Clause, TruthOut is reporting that Weinstein’s MRFF is again complaining about an outside Christian organization having access to the Pentagon. This time it was David Kistler’s HOPE ministries.
The article makes it unclear whether it is the theology that is the issue (since much of the article is a mockery of Kistler’s views) or the fact it was a religious organization.
While the writer makes it appear that it is “intuitively obvious” that the Pentagon again violated the ‘Constitutional separation of church and state,’ that is not the case. Chaplains routinely host outside visitors of varied religious persuasions for the spiritual benefit of their servicemen, which is their legal duty.
While Weinstein may disagree, the Constitution and the courts have supported the religious influence of the chaplaincy and its programs in the military.
The Best Intentions…
According to the International Herald Tribune, the US military apologized for offending Afghani Muslims when it gave them soccer balls that had the Saudi flag on it. The Saudi flag has the words Allah and Muhammad on it; those names in any form are considered sacred to Muslims. The thought of kicking those sacred names was apparently offensive.
Soccer (or football, outside the US), is wildly popular in most other parts of the world, and has even been a source of national pride in an otherwise sometimes fractious Iraq.
A local paper covers the perspectives of Chaplain Douglas Etter, a Presbyterian Chaplain in the Army National Guard, and Commander Jon Cutler, a Navy Jewish Chaplain, in Military Chaplains Serve Diverse Roles. (Scroll down if the screen formatting appears blank.) With thanks to Religion Clause for the point out.
Joe Carter of the National Review wrote an article on CNN’s “God’s Warriors” in which he noted that while many people are concerned about CNN juxtaposing assassins and Falwell, what CNN is really doing is proposing “equivalency of ideology.” That is, Islam, Judaism, and Christianity are “equal.” He notes, for example, that while “theocracy” is a theology most aligned with Islam, it is more often attributed to Protestant Christians. In fact,
more than half of American evangelicals are either Baptists or nondenominational — groups that don’t even want a centralized church government much less a central government controlled by the church.
The Culture and Media Institute also wrote an article on the CNN series. It contains some positive and negative things about the shows, including Amanpour’s comparison of Christian calls for “modest dress” as equivalent with the Taliban calls for burkas.
Michael Weinstein opines about the state of Christianity in the military in a relatively tame editorial in the LA Times.
As previously posted, CNN’s special on “God’s Warriors” runs this week.
The CNN site lists the topics as:
Judaism: Murder in Hebron and Settler vs. Soldier
Islam: Holy Killing and Martyrdom
Christianity: Christians and Falwell and The Culture War
With murder and holy killing juxtaposed with Falwell and a culture war, it is fairly easy to see why some are worried that CNN will equate evangelical Christians with radical Islam.
Their “objectivity” remains to be seen.
The ACLJ recently responded to the release of the Pentagon Inspector General’s report. They said
We think the legal conclusions of the Department of Defense Inspector General are incorrect as a matter of fact and as a matter of law.
They also stated that they represent two of the officers, including the retired Chaplain who was the focus of much of the report.
See the FRC response and original post below.