Michael Weinstein Opposes Bible, Supports Koran in Military
Michael Weinstein has repeatedly demonstrated an animosity toward the association of the US military with the Christian Bible. In 2009, his Military Religious Freedom Foundation opposed a Chaplain bringing Swahili Bibles to Iraq, despite the fact they were requested by third country nationals supporting the US military effort. The “religious freedom” organization opposed support for the religious freedom of US allies.
In 2007, Weinstein highly publicized a cropped photograph of a US Army trainee posing with his M-16 and his Bible — alongside a similarly photographed Hamas suicide bomber. (The photos can be seen here; the original article was written by Jason Leopold, currently an editor for TruthOut, for which Weinstein is a board member and fundraiser.) Weinstein’s MRFF is quoted saying “fundamentalist Christianity” in the US military “is starting to mirror Islamic fundamentalism.” (Tellingly, he never made similar statements about photos of Jewish Soldiers and their weapons, some of which can be seen here.)
Weinstein’s most recent complaint is apparently in a hallway of quotes at the Air Force Academy. One of the quotes in the hallway is allegedly from the Bible.
In an odd contrast, Weinstein seems to be supportive of associations of the Koran with military service. Though he was upstaged by CAIR in the press, Weinstein promised to send one Koran to the Afghan National Army — notably, not Afghan civilians — for every one Florida Pastor Terry Jones burned. In addition, he publicly stated his intent to have the US military deliver the religious texts to Afghanistan. Apparently, he and his organization oppose an American military Chaplain providing asked-for Bibles, but support official military distribution of Korans even when they’re not requested. His hypocrisy wasn’t well received even by his own supporters, some of whom recanted their prior financial support of his organization as a result.
Ironically, the Department of Defense recently published an article on the swearing-in of Afghan National Army recruits. In the accompanying photos, the US-backed military recruits take their oath to support “God and Country” on Korans laying next to their US-supplied weapons:
Official Caption:
Recruits take the oath of enlistment during an Afghan National Army ceremony in Regional Military Training Center – Kandahar. More than 1400 recruits renewed their vow to defend Afghanistan and its people by placing their hands over the Koran and swearing to be faithful to god and country. (Photo by Petty Officer 2nd Class Ernesto Hernandez Fonte)
Weinstein’s Koran stunt was little more than an opportunistic ploy for publicity, a late-game effort to coat-tail on the international attention Jones was receiving. (The Jones brouhaha had nothing to do with religious freedom in the US military.) That he was willing to take such a step, though, again demonstrates the intellectual inconsistency of his actions with his stated position.
In this instance, Weinstein’s prior condemnation of Christian activities in the US military contradicts his public plans to support non-Christian ones. Despite his claim of defending the Constitution, his true agenda could not be more clear — and it has nothing to do with “religious freedom” in the US military.
If Jones had followed through on this plans to burn the Korans, the Afghan military recruits could have been swearing their allegiance on Korans supplied by Weinstein’s MRFF, in a display of religious association Weinstein would supposedly oppose. Would he have claimed they, like US Christians, were a mirror of Hamas?
Given that its Christianity with which Weinstein is “at war,” it doesn’t seem likely.
I followed the case where Bibles, translated into Pashtun and other Afghan tribal languages, had been sent to Afghanistan. I found that disturbing because it implied a clear desire on someone’s part to proselytize to Afgan nationals, in direct contravention of General Order 1B. I haven’t found that to be the case with the Jewish chaplains I’ve met, nor with others in their faith group.
Also, consider that Afghanistan is an Islamic Republic. The United States, by contrast, doesn’t — and shouldn’t — have an official religion. And that’s a Good Thing™, because honestly, I don’t want any government deciding which religious beliefs are okay and which ones aren’t.
I normally disagree with just about every article on this website, but not this one. A good point was made that about MRFF. When you believe in a cause so much, you often times make irrational decisions. I can understand where Weinstein was coming from, but I can in no way support it.
Phoenix Blue also made a very good point. Military chaplains are placed in a difficult situation in that they have to serve God (spread the word) AND following the laws of a secular organization. Sometimes chaplains falter on the latter part and more often than not it is Christian chaplains.
Pingback: God and Country » Christmas in Afghanistan, Presidential Message on Jesus’ Birth
I took that photo you used and wrote the article you refferenced. I don’t see anything ironic about the DOD releasing such a photo/article.
You said U.S. backed recruits and it made it sounds like recruits swearing on the Koran is U.S. supported. I can assure you it’s not.
As stated in my caption this is an Afghan National Army ceremony. It’s the Afghan Army’s tradition not ours and we have no right in my opinion to force a different tradition or secularism down their throat.
Islam is a big part of their national identity the mixing of religion and other parts of society is pretty common here.
If they had more military journalist it wouldn’t be a DOD photo it would be an Afghan Ministry of Defense photo. They don’t at the moment though.
Ernesto — the term “US-backed military recruits” means that the US supports them, their cause, their fight and provides training, weapons and other assistance. Absolutely nothing to do with their oath to support “God and Country” by swearing on the Koran…that is their [Afghans] practice/right to do so and no US policy is supported or not supported for it.
Our troops swear to support and defend the Constitution of the United States….