US Military Implicates Five Soldiers in Quran Burning

Various reports indicate the US military has identified five soldiers (and an Afghan-American interpreter) who are “responsible” for burning the Quran at Bagram Air Base, Afghanistan.  The Islamic holy texts (which were reportedly defiled by Islamic detainees) were among more than 1,600 books and other materials intended for destruction due to their apparent use by detainees to pass messages.

The probe launched by the top U.S. commander in Afghanistan, Marine Gen. John R. Allen, is still underway, but five soldiers were involved in the incident, NBC News reported Friday.

A careful reading of the reports indicates it is possible not a single one of the five involved knew there were Korans among the texts. 

Obviously, the results of the American investigation were made public to some end, which may only fuel the calls for Americans to be put on trial in Afghanistan (including by the Afghan President):

Afghanistan’s senior religious leaders have said that an apology alone will not do. They want the responsible troops to be put on a public trial.

While al Jazeera made it a point to say the soldiers “face reprimand,” no responsible party — even “anonymous military officials” — has yet said what crime the Americans committed, or what policy they violated.  Even so, “anonymous officials” said the soldiers might still face punishment:

It appears that the soldiers will not face criminal charges, anonymous military officials were quoted as saying. The troops may face non-judicial punishment, which could be as simple as a reprimand…

“For the soldiers, it will be serious — they could lose rank. But you’re not going to see the kind of public trial that some here seem to want,” said one U.S. military official.

Todd Starnes at FoxNews poetically framed “the day the US military burned the Bible in Afghanistan.”  As has been noted before, and in a few other places, unlike the Korans, the US military intentionally burned Christian Bibles in the trash, and then defended doing so.  By contrast, the Korans were burned by “mistake,” and everyone from the commanding General in Afghanistan, Marine General John Allen, to the President of the United States has apologized for the incident.  General Allen has reportedly ordered new training on how to handle Korans; many Soldiers already go through training directing them to “respect” Islam

al Jazeera may also have made the most prescient statement:

“The way that the Americans and the Afghan government handle the conclusions of this report, and handle [the situation] … that is going to be crucial to how the reaction is here on the streets of Afghanistan.”

The “streets of Afghanistan,” of course, should have no impact on the moral conduct, protection of human liberties, and military decision making by US and coalition forces — but that doesn’t mean it won’t.  US Army Col (Ret) Peter Mansoor, who was previously an executive officer to Gen. David Petraeus in Iraq, wondered aloud if the American military leadership has become so inclined to defend Islam that it is losing focus:

Americans have cultural sensitivities, too. Maybe we’re so sensitive to Afghan culture that we’re forgetting our own.

The US mission in Afghanistan might be helped most by promoting the American ideals of religious liberty and tolerance.  By contrast, current perceptions run the risk of appearing to promote the value of one religion over another.  Such a perception may yield positive results in the short-term, but it is one that may backfire in the end.

With reference to


  • I highly doubt we’re so sensitive to Afghan culture that we’re forgetting our own, and this has nothing to do with this situation. If burning the book(s) was a mistake, then so be it. Although it will be hard to convince the Afghans of this, and no matter if it was intentional or not, they want them to be punished. If it were intentional, it would also be hard to prove. Our troops are protected by the UCMJ, why would they be punished at all if they are not guilty…and there is no “they should have known better” fault just to have scap-goats either.

    It’s way past time to leave that horrible country and bring our troops home; we leave them nothing and no money from our tax dollars go there either. No American is safe over there, we are the infidels and must die no matter what…there words, not mine.

    O believers, take not Jews and Christians as friends; they are friends of each other. Those of you who make them his friends is one of them. God does not guide an unjust people. – 5:54

    O Prophet! Make war on the unbelievers and the hypocrites. Be harsh with them. Their ultimate abode is hell, a hapless journey’s end. – 9:73

    Lots more of KORAN commands to kill infidels: (I did not read in a Koran to verify, but someones can if interested)

  • Pingback: God and Country » US Soldiers who Burned Korans Receive Punishment